Friday, 6 January 2023

The way we navigate in the digital age

 The way we navigate in the digital age or how to avoid being another ship wreck. 

Sometimes I think we forget just how lucky we are to be navigating in the digital age. We haven’t always had so much choice for positioning and displaying our position. Watch keeping has been made easier with GPS, AIS, HD RADAR’s and even voyage data recorders.  The Global Navigation Satellite System receivers are good enough to place you with reasonable precision and some modern RADAR units are now good enough to pick up bamboo poles and little wood canoes. AIS is a great tool to display ships, beacons and lights as we travel the seas and oceans. Both RADAR and AIS have the ability to easily confirm the yacht position that's plotted on the chart. 

AIS can certainly help in congested waterways. Beware not to get overwhelmed with the amount of data. Instrument or chartplotter adjustments can limit the amount of information displayed to help overcome the creation of  a data overloaded situation. 

Forecasting of Weather

Another major advance in ship safety is the forecasting of weather. It doesn’t seem all that long ago that those with very deep pockets had a weather fax.  However, for the rest of us we would listen to the radio or buy the newspaper to get the latest forecast before we set sail. We now have a multitude of sources to get weather forecasts. We can download weather faxes on the HF or receive them via email or down load them from the internet. GRIB files can be downloaded from several sources. We would get GRIB files over Sailmail on the HF or download from the internet when closer to shore.  Other cruisers we sailed with would use their sat phones and get forecasts including downloading GRIB files. 

Nice GRIB file display, up to a weeks forecast at our finger tips any time of the day. GRIB file collected and displayed  on zyGRIB part of OpenPlotter package running on a Raspberry Pi. We are able to select local time to display the information so we don't need to convert UTC to local which becomes tiring after a while. 

Data Overload

The only drawback, if there is one, to the many advances and abundant information from a variety of sources is how we use the information. Beware, don’t follow the data blindly, as we have found there is still interpretation and analysis to be done. However we have also found some get so caught up in information collection they get an over load and neglect to do the analysis when confronted by so much data.  If your chart starts to look too overloaded with objects here is a description of hotkeys to remove clutter quickly.

Its a process of elimination

Keep it simple and find through a process of elimination the tools that suite you the best. When we went offshore we were offered a lot of data files with information of the places we intended to visit. While in the beginning this seemed like a fantastic windfall, then as we started to sift through the info we found is was difficult to correlate some of the conflicting information. We would hear that one place was absolutely fantastic and then the next guide we would read to steer clear. So sort your data carefully and remember things change and any info over six to seven years may be questionable. Some things don't change but there is an enormous flexible area in between. 

We will discuss some we use, and the ways to cross check available data. We have even noticed some of the big instrument makers are adding more and more features all the time that can cause confusion. Unfortunately we already have a lot of Nintendo sailors out there. Yep its a term in use now days that describes the sailors who look at the screen more than out to the horizon. While the screens do carry a fantastic assortment of information, managing the vessel on a voyage with your head down looking at a monitor is a good way to become a statistic. 

False Sense of Security

We talked with some cruisers recently that believed the precision of their electronic charts were so good that they were accurate to within a few metres. Wouldn’t this be good to have charts as accurate as the position output from the GNSS receiver connected to the chartplotter? Unfortunately this isn’t the case. A lot of the time I presume, due to ignorance, some would not hear a cautionary word spoken and really why would they need to be careful when using commercially produced electronic charts? large ships do. The answer to large ships using electronic charts with reasonable confidence is, that they steam down very well used sea lanes into busy ports that are consistently being surveyed for obstructions and navigational hazards. The large ships are not venturing off the sea lanes into poorly charted areas, as most cruising vessels do.

An electronic chart segment not referenced to WGS 84. Datum unknown and the vessels were positioned by GPS. The chart does contain good information though, range and bearing info can give you an idea of how far to offset the vessel position on the chart so as to use the depth information or avoid upcoming obstacles. 

As an example of how dangerous this false sense of security can be, when passage planning we start work by checking our intended passage on the chartplotter. Some of the time we will find that the electronic chart will state plainly that satellite positions obtained using WGS 84 datum cannot be plotted on this chart. For those not familiar with the term WGS 84, it means the datum used to calculate a position solution of modern GPS satellites. We have also seen the same area displayed with all its hazards by a different brand of electronic chart, with out the caution. 

The small print on the chart states that the chart cannot accurately be referenced to WGS84 Datum, with out a reference point or datum, extreme care is needed to navigate in this area if your using GPS as a positioning source.  


Passage planning comparing various sources of information. 

Charts Not Totally Suitable for Pilotage

While our travels progressed and we ventured to places favoured more by fishermen and cruisers than commercial marine traffic we began to see more and more chart abnormalities.

We have been cruising in a lot of remote tropical and semi tropical regions for the last ten years and I will admit that at times it has been interesting, especially where the charts were not totally suitable for pilotage. That’s not to say there were not any official charts of the areas we were in, often the charts that do exist are old, well in other words haven’t been updated and reprinted with new survey data.  Or there may not have been any hydrographic surveys done for years. Additionally, but to a lesser extent, some of the older local datum may have carried over into recent revisions of the charts. Then it is carried forward again as the paper charts were digitised into the apparently modern electronic ones. The differences can occasionally be hundreds of metres.

Older paper chart, info box chart datum isn't specific. GPS positions cannot be plotted on this chart. Note the positions of the reefs and island being reported to be out of position to the chart. 

Electronic chart with the reefs in the same place noted as being out of place on the paper chart. On closer inspection of this electronic chart, it appeared to be a pretty copy of the paper chart that can not have GPS (WGS 84 Datum) positions plotted on. Another brand of electronic chart did list the fact that satellite positions could not be plotted on the chart in the lower layers. 

We always have one or at times two people on lookout when needed. The RADAR is ready to provide range and bearing measurements.  Keep in mind RADAR range measurements can be accurate, use two or three ranges to obtain a fix. The same cannot be said for bearing measurements as the average RADAR beam is 5 degrees or more. The image on the screen may seem stretched and because of this, making an exact bearing measurement can be difficult. As with every tool, calibration is important, making sure the angles and ranges that are displayed are correct before heading off on a passage. 

Time to get on the bow when closing on an entrance

Sailing Directions and Planning Guides 

When spending time planning our route and ensuring we didn’t see any obstructions on the chart along the way.  We made good use of the sailing directions and planning guides put out by the U.S. NATIONAL GEO SPATIAL-INTELLIGENCE AGENCY. Sailing Directions (Planning Guides) include relevant physical, political, industrial, navigational and regulatory information about the countries adjacent to a particular ocean basin in a single volume. 

Sailing Directions and Guides

From experience the most challenging charts are the ones that lack any fine detail. To cover this lack of data we have found chart makers have marked these areas as shallows or very shallow, even though there is in a lot cases navigable water depth.  Even with the newer charts, in a lot of cases the charts do not have sufficient detail to allow yachts and smaller vessels to easily venture out of the shipping lanes or major ports to explore and find safe anchorages. 

Electronic chart showing limited detail, lagoon depth info not existent. 

Satellite photo chart adds enough detail to allow us to find a protected anchorage over night. 

Nice anchorage for the evening. 

To keep things interesting, in the warmer tropical waters, coral can grow at a surprisingly alarming rate when the conditions are right. What was a clear channel when charted 100 years ago or for that matter even 25 years ago might now have coral bommies close enough to the surface to catch the average cruising yachts keel.  

Getting from here to there is going to need all eyes on deck, and good satellite photo charts.

Several Ship Wrecks 

Some charts we have encountered list that the depths are not from recent surveys but from single transit lines and there was no reference to when or the vessel type, depth sounder or lead line. But I guess in the long run the message is clear, coral heads and obstructions may well exist, missed by the vessels on a transit. If you notice on the chart several ship wrecks scattered about in a small area of supposed open water be careful, even to the point of having crew posted on the bow as look out. Why did these ships sink? They more than likely hit something not charted in the area, then steamed on until loosing the battle with the incoming water they sank. 

ABC of Passage Planning 

The cruising skipper/navigator needs to piece together every available bit of information in advance, and for us, satellite imagery as an additional navigation aide has proven to be successful. Even before we left Australia and were exploring the east coast we adopted a range of techniques to supplement standard navigation and pilotage practices. We started to use the freely available satellite imagery to fill in the gaps and give us the support to explore and make safe passages even when going off the beaten track. One rule we follow now days is the A.B.C of passage planning: Assume nothing, Believe nothing, and Check every thing...

Chart of a reef on the left is missing detail, the same area on the right satellite photo showing the real extent of the reef , and while not marked on the chart there are large metal tower beacons on both sides on the edge of the coral marking the channel between the reefs

We now make navigation safer using satellite images

The availability of satellite imagery for us while passage planning and navigating is a huge jump forward. It has allowed us to explore with acceptable confidence. Due to the additional information satellite imagery provides we can usually find safe alternatives when plan ‘A’ doesn’t pan out as we would have liked. Unfortunately some think this imagery is available in different platforms and can be used as a standalone tool, but it can’t and is really only an additional tool, however it has proven to be a very good one.  In reality the use of satellite imagery does not replace traditional methods of navigation and pilotage, it enhances it.

Waypoint for anchorage plotted on standard electronic chart, not a lot of detail.

The same waypoint plotted on a satellite photo chart. More detail of the surrounding area, and clear vision of the fringing reef. 

When we are given waypoints or find them published in anchoring/cruising guides we always plot them on the chart and satellite images. Experience has taught us to now treat every piece of information given to us with caution, especially when there appears to be some form of ambiguity. As an example we were given a list of waypoints for various anchorages in less travelled parts. What wasn’t making sense was the names of the islands were not what we were seeing on our charts. As it turns out the waypoints originally came from a European vessel. The spelling of the island names were different on their charts. We usually find the biggest challenge is to extract clear fact.  On several occasions we have found serious errors that would have lead us into danger. We quickly found that satellite imagery will, in a lot of incidents provide weighty evidence to support the final evaluation.  

Waypoints plotted on an electronic chart, the anchorage waypoints look ok with reasonable protection when plotted on an electronic chart. 

The same waypoints plotted on a satellite photo chart referenced to WGS 84 datum. The anchorage waypoints certainly have lost their appeal, and one is high and dry. Who really knows where the author anchored. 

Here is an example of the quality of some of the guides or information we have been given. We head for a waypoint and the reported depth is 6 - 8 metres in sand. When at the waypoint it’s over 20 metres deep.  A quick search of the area for the reported depth proves fruitless and in frustration not wanting to be in total darkness when we finish for the day, we drop the anchor to find it grinds on coral.  Sadly we found this will not be an isolated incident. We have also been given waypoints where the fine detail is missing and the waypoints are only in the vicinity waypoint. Where the author actually anchored will require detective work. We like to do the detective work before getting there, saves frustration at the end of a day’s travel.    

Not what you want to see when picking up the anchor.

Check the Geodetic Datum

Please remember before sharing waypoints check the geodetic datum used while collecting the data. Publish the results with the waypoints so corrections if needed can be applied before use. Please don’t pull out a paper chart with unknown datum a week later and say with confidence we anchored here and pin point the place on the paper chart where you think you anchored. Keep a log and actually read off the position from your GPS/GNSS receiver when the anchor is down. While this may sound crazy, check your satellite receiver regularly. On a number of occasions we have been given waypoints that when plotted would suggest a different receiver datum was mistakenly used and not WGS84, or as I said earlier it was wild guess work after leaving the anchorage.  Either that or they had an air cushioned vessel flying over reefs, or anchored their deep keel yacht in less than a metre of water, somehow I don’t think either is true.

This is an easy check to do on the chartplotter or GNSS receiver. 

Most people will be familiar with using satellite photos to explore. Coverage extends over most coastal waters and details most of the shoals, reefs and rocks. However, there are patches of the shore line and islands that are not shown due to the cloaking in what should be the offshore areas. This removes detail from areas where it has been determined it does not need to be shown and more than likely reduces download data. These areas including island/reefs/rocks not shown are usually due to being misplaced on the “Official Charts”. In the same area the reverse may be true and areas are uncloaked on the satellite imagery will contain no island/reefs/rock hazard. In this case extreme caution needs to be used when navigating in these areas, as you will find a hazard on the official chart that is not in the correct charted location. Or more to the point, the chart datum used for the position of the obstacle possibly had inaccuracies. Using a different program (SASplanet for us) that is connected to other satellite image resources may show the hazard, and the position of it can be found.

Satellite photo showing cloaked details. The positions used to uncloak the position where the island was charted as being, was most likely from a chart that was not referenced to satellite positions. So the opening in the cloak is not over the island which needs extra care to be taken when in the area 

Different source of satellite photo data showing islands, cloaking isn't noticeable on this shot 

In all but the most heavily polluted waters or areas near a large muddy river it is clear enough for shallow areas to be visible on satellite imagery. Even in slightly murky water as in the Malacca Strait, irregular discoloured patches can be distinguished. Due to the way the satellite images are compiled they can easily be referenced to WGS84 for plotting GPS positions on them. These features combine to provide a powerful tool to supplement traditional navigation and pilotage.

What technology tools do we use on board?

Software:
Windows 10/11 running on a laptop
Google Earth
SAS Planet which allows selectable satellite image resources 
Raspberry Pi with OpenPlotter image, OpenCPN, satellite imagery overlay charts and various soft tools
Laptop running OpenCPN with Satellite Imagery overlay charts as well as a plug-in to display Google Earth directly from the web or from the cache on the hard drive. 
OpenCPN also is great for displaying GRIB files and we set it up to read local time, so we don't continually need to calculate UTC to local.
Raymarine Chartplotter running Navionics electronic charts
SAT2CHART software for creating satellite image charts 
GERoute to collect satellite imagery into the Google Earth cache
Various software to manipulate, edit, repair (GPX) GPS files (tracks, routes, waypoints)
Tide and current prediction programs, WXTIDE32, OpenCPN, Total Tide, 


Hardware:

HD RADAR, we use this to tie in local features to the cockpit chart plotter. In a lot of cases we can gauge just how far land masses are offset on the charted WGS84 datum. We can also use it to do range and bearing fixes to plot our position. We also use it to accurately measure vessel distance from other vessels or obstacles when anchoring. 

Raymarine Chartplotter, Raymarine active GPS antenna, 
Wi-Fi access point, NMEA positioning data is transmitted ship wide over a Wi-Fi Access Point (AP)
Android Tablet running Navionics charts (Position data is from an internal GPS receiver or via Wi-Fi) 
Garmin GPS 73 handheld 
Hand bearing compasses
Paper Charts, Portland plotter, protractor, etc.
Laptop running Windows 10/11, Raspberry Pi 4 with OpenPlotter image


As listed earlier in our navigation station we have a Raspberry Pi with OpenPlotter image, positioning data is supplied by a connected GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System: e.g. GPS, GLONASS, QZSS) receiver. Reception is very good due to the external antenna. As a backup we also have a USB port powered GNSS receiver dongle. Reception is good enough from its location behind the chart table, although this might not be the case on all boats, due to deck and hull construction material or methods. I use a laptop with Windows 11 because it’s a stable common platform for all the various, charting, navigation, tide, file creation, editing and conversion software we use. 

The laptop and peripherals are charged by DC/DC power adaptors so we can conserve power and we do not need to run an inverter.  This laptop uses a NMEA positioning data feed off the vessels Raymarine active GPS antenna, which is networked electrically as well as wireless (Wi-Fi) throughout the vessel and supplies positioning data to the cockpit chartplotter. We run OpenCPN on both the Raspberry Pi and the laptop, this avoids compatibility problems when exchanging self-created files between the two systems and with other cruisers. Here is a short article we did on power basics.

DC power supplies to run the laptop, we got this lot on eBay the first ones we had were from a computer shop, a little more expensive though. The biggest problem when sourcing these adapters is finding the right sales person who understands you want 12volt DC power supply with the correct voltage output for your laptop. Also keep in mind 12 volt USB chargers for phones and a lot of small electronics are available from most car part shops or online through eBay or Amazon 
12 Volt to USB adaptors and a unit that can be hardwired into the ships nav station. 

I would like to mention that with this push to Wi-Fi connectivity there appears to have a weak link, being electrical storm activity. We have experienced this several times, at the height of the storm we lost Wi-Fi inter-connectivity, which was very inconvenient at the time. So to counteract this we don’t use wireless connections on critical systems and if we do, we have a hard wired backup system. 

Part of the nav station, Bolt 4G modem (upper right) powered by USB adaptor. External antenna can be connected in marginal reception areas. Centre screen is the OpenPlotter set up running on a Raspberry Pi, connecting to the 4G modem via Wi-Fi allows downloads of GRIB files. GRIB file on display here using zyGRIB 

We try and maintain 4G access to the internet to download the images on the go. We have a dedicated 4G mobile modem router with external antenna, or we can use the mobile phone as a hot-spot (tether) for the laptop and Raspberry Pi. In some parts of Australia and Asia (Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia) when close to the coast the coverage is good enough to allow file/satellite imagery downloads as you travel along. However, I really cannot recommend this in case you encounter a blind spot and loose coverage.  Normally, we passage plan ahead for the areas of satellite imagery coverage needed and download when we can. When headed into the more remote parts of Australia and Asia we have had to plan up to a month in advance and collect satellite imagery while we have had a good internet connection. 

Raspberry Pi acting as and access point, allows sharing data between devices. As shown a tablet, phone and the main screen. The raspberry Pi has an access point and is also connected to the 4G modem allowing the connected screens to access the internet as well as display navigations data. The navigation can be a clone of the main screen or you can use another charting program like Navionics. 

Google Earth Cache

Google Earth can be run live streaming from the internet or it caches (automatically saves) viewed imagery up to a user selectable pre-set storage size limit. You can adjust and make the most of this cache size in the program settings (Tools/Options, Cache tab). In more remote areas you will need to prepare all your satellite image charts in advance. During the planning stage of your trip while you have a good internet connection, traverse a planned route zooming in and panning as you go along. The detail saved (cached) is automatically adjusted as you zoom. 

Google earth setting up the cache limit for memory and disk.  


You can even explore archived images from previous years to find the clearest pictures. This is not an option when using SASplanet so keep this option in mind if you have trouble finding a recent clear satellite photo. 

Provided you don’t exceed the pre-selected storage limit, all the images will be available later when you are under way and not connected to the internet. The setting to have the archive selection tool visible is in the settings tab (View, Historical Imagery).

If you’re thinking it’s going to get tedious sitting and moving the curser over a pre-set route to collect a cache of Google Earth satellite images, you can breathe a sigh of relief, a program called GERoute is available as a free down load and is written specifically to follow a route to load up the Google Earth cache. Link is supplied in the resources.

You can connect a GPS to Google Earth, (Tools, GPS tab) we use a USB GNSS dongle.  Your boat location will be shown on the satellite imagery in Google Earth. I know it does work and have tested it, but have never used this option stand alone. 

Note: About the use of Google Earth caches. At the start of the journey or during passage planning, if you’re anchored at a major town the internet connection is fast and secure.  If you use the caching method saving imagery for later use, my suggestion is that once you have collected the data turn off the internet connection for that device you have cached the images on (laptop). Then when on passage and you have Google Earth open, keep the connection off, this saves the imagery database (cache) from being corrupted by being over written. With no internet connection to the laptop the Google Earth cache is not over written. The program will complain about not having a connection when first opened but will run using cached data. 

OpenCPN displays

OpenCPN is a concise and robust open source chart plotting software that is freely available for download. It is the product of an online community of volunteer programmers. Electronic charts can be displayed and overlaid with waypoints, routes and tracks. Also available for download is a whole range of additional plugins that add a versatile range of functionality. One of these plugins is a Google Earth display, this allows an additional window on the OpenCPN screen, on one will be displayed Google Earth imagery and on the other will be the electronic chart. The boat position will be shown on both mediums on the screen.

OpenCPN display, Google Earth plugin running to display a satellite photo and the boats position. Google earth can be using cache files or a live internet feed. 
  

You can also create your own geo referenced Satellite Imagery charts using another free to download program called SAT2CHART which is used in association with Google Earth, SAS Planet and OpenCPN. These created charts can then be imported into OpenCPN and overlaid onto the electronic navigation charts. You can toggle between the satellite images and the chart to compare features. 

Satellite photo chart referenced to WGS 84, display is overlaid on the electronic chart.



OpenCPN dual display in action, electronic chart on the left and satellite photo chart right side, with this setup you are able to run different scales on either chart. 

Also keep in mind there have been a lot of satellite imagery charts made by fellow cruisers and some have become available for download. Links in resources

SAS Planet

SAS Planet is another Geographic Information System (GIS), similar but different to Google Earth due to being able to select a variety of charts/satellite images. It is a Russian freeware program, readily available for download. This program is simple to use and does not need to be installed. You just move it from the download folder into its own folder and then double click the downloaded file to make it run.

Many cruisers, our self-included are now using SAS Planet because it provides access to images from other sources, such as Bing and Yahoo. In some areas these are better quality than the Google Earth images. Unfortunately, we have found many of the different sourced images can have cloaked areas like the Google Earth cloak.  If you’re looking for a clear image search through the different sources and try to find uncloaked images to pinpoint hazards.

Screen shots taken from SASplanet

Example of a cloaked area, reef detail under cloak. Looking at the image you should be able to make out the area of reef under the cloak, further investigation needed

A different source of satellite photo showing the extent of the reef

And the same area again with yet another carrier, all three were easily selectable in a  key stroke.

Like Google Earth, SAS Planet has the ability to be connected to your GPS so that you can see your boat’s position on the satellite images. You can also use SAS Planet like a chartplotter to create waypoints and routes as well as record your tracks, keep in mind it has very few other features. 

SAS Planet can be used for converting the images into charts for later use in OpenCPN and this is straight forward with the program SAT2Chart. When on passage if you do not have access to the internet, you’ll have to rely on images stored in the cache if you haven’t made charts. As with any cache it is limited by the amount of storage space allocated. The same rule applies to SAS Planet as Google Earth, keep your internet connection turned off when running the program in fringe internet coverage areas or you will risk corrupting your collected cache. The program also has switches to select what data to use and display (live or cached). 

With good internet coverage or a good store of cashed images OpenCPN and SAS Planet used together is a good option. 

Ovital Map

No longer an option it was breaching Google copyright and was stopped for a while. We briefly used this program written by the Chinese. Ovital Map is a map browser developed by Beijing Ovital Software Co. However we didn't feel it was for us.  While this may be a good program and is loved by a lot of people we found there were more options available with SAS Planet, we still have it installed as a backup on the laptop but haven't used it in a long time. This program will use caches or live connection to the web. The same limitations as working with Google Earth.

GpsGate

If you only have one GPS serial/USB/dongle, you can install software that makes the GPS input available to two or more programs at once. Download the program GpsGate which is free, easy to install and use. This will allow you to connect two GPS applications to the one GPS in order to run both at once on the same laptop. 

SAT2CHART

KAP & Mbtiles files (satellite image overlay charts) 

When we were headed into far North Queensland and then on to SE Asia. We knew that satellite imagery was going to be a real asset. However, we also knew that going into some of these regions the internet is not good enough for downloading a lot of data. So before we left port we used GE2KAP (now SAT2CHART) to assemble a collection of satellite photo charts for the planned ports of call and hazards we saw were along the way. Cruisers who knew we were headed into SE Asia gave us copies of the KAP files they themselves had assembled before and while cruising Asia. These KAP charts did prove invaluable tools for passage planning and finding protected anchorages throughout our trip. 

In the past the standard file format was a .KAP and while good, a new standard is being used and the file extension is .Mbtiles. This new standard allows user created files to have far better resolution and coverage area than was available previously, giving the user a clearer picture of any hazards.

Running software to make a satellite chart, its fairly automatic once your set up. 

Satellite image charts proved to be invaluable

When travelling into remote areas you need to prepare all your satellite image charts in advance. We spent several months cruising in Indonesia and we quickly found not all the islands, reefs and atolls have been charted in detail. In fact there are still some that have yet to be named. In a lot of cases the charts are dated (late 1800’s or early 1900’s) and there are plenty of omissions and inaccuracies.  We did find one or two paper charts had disclaimers stating not to use the latitude and longitude of the chart but take sights to visible features to work out where you are on the chart (comforting). In a lot of cases it appears the origin datum of the chart was lost in the mists of time. 

In these areas our collection of satellite image charts proved to be invaluable, allowing us to explore further and providing us with enough information to find useful protected anchorages.

A typical electronic chart from an industry leader in the leisure craft charts. The area around the island looks clear judging by the chart.  

The same area on a satellite photo chart we made using the SAT2CHART program. Our track (yellow line) where it becomes squiggly, shows where we hovered and stood off just in-case, as a sail boat was dragged off the little reef  (visible to the right of where we stood off) by several local fishermen. 

Those who have cruised in the convergence zones will know that you should always have an exit from your anchorage. As we have experienced first hand, storms and violent wind shifts can turn a slice of tropical paradise into a lee shore with a fetch across an ocean. Having the satellite image charts and a recorded track allows us to have a plan ready for these situations. We always save our tracks and can go back to places we have been in reasonable confidence. Once every couple of days we save them off the pc onto a disk to save space on the main drive. 

GRIB files

An important tool for the navigator in the digital age is the use of GRIB over lay weather charts. We use data from several sources. In addition, the main ones are our Openplotter package has zyGRIB installed, a nice collection and display program as part of the package. The same downloaded files can also be displayed through OpenCPN and overlaid directly on the chart/satellite image with better chart detail. OpenCPN also has a plugin with the ability to weather route using GRIBS.

GRIB file display in OpenCPN data, several sources for download available online. 

We have a SailMail account and with it comes access to the Saildocs GRIB repository. We can access this via the internet, HF radio with practor modem or via a satellite phone. We can display the files through the SailMail Airmail program, OpenCPN or zyGRIB programs. We do like using OpenCPN on the PC and zyGRIB on the Raspberry to display the GRIBS due to the fact we can display using local time, we don’t have to continually convert UTC to local which can become tiresome.

I have mentioned these programs that download files due to the fact mobile phone apps while pretty and contain a lot of data unfortunately are not much good once you are out of range of the phone towers. Look for mobile phone applications that allow the downloading of GRIBS for display at a later time. While I don’t use this myself I have seen and liked the look of Predict Wind Offshore, a download before a passage allows the data to be available for display later. 

Whatever you use, think about data usage when away from the more populated towns. I do know the GRIBS we download have been optimised for data use and transmission over slow internet connections, and in some remote villages we did just that. While friends we were travelling with could not get any GRIBS downloaded on to their tablets or mobile phones in areas of limited internet connections. 

To sum up.

Last but very very important, zoom in your chartplotter, I have lost count of the number of times have I heard "we ran onto an unmarked rock/reef/obstruction that was not charted" in most cases, not all, the reality is that "it" was charted however it was not visible in the layer of zoom the chartplotter was in. Experiment with zoom levels and check it out for yourself. 

Declutter your screen when needed

Some thing you may want to do from time to time is declutter your chart display when it becomes cluttered with detail. We have seen areas where there have been so much text and detail on the chart it actually becomes confusing. A quick way to do this is with hotkeys, make your self a cheat sheet so its at your finger tips. Link to a short hotkey description

The satellite images are an additional tool, not a standalone system. Again we have met cruisers who do follow the satellite images blindly and dismiss other sources of information. Be aware some of the satellite photos are old and as I have said before things can change.   

Remember a reasonably good GPS receiver will give positions <15 metres 95% of the time. Some of the newer GNSS units can do better but remember the chart you’re using may not be as accurate as the GPS/GNSS unit.

If you want to run two programs that require a GPS and only have one GPS feed/dongle you can install software (GpsGate) that makes the GPS input available to two or more programs at once. For example, Google Earth and SAS Planet at the same time.  

Both Google Earth and SAS Planet can collect and store satellite imagery in a user selectable pre-set storage size cache. This imagery can be used when there is no internet connection later during the passage. This Google Earth data cannot be permanently saved, the cache will be over written when next on line and Google Earth is started. However, I believe a copy of the SAS Planet cache data can be made, worthwhile to fall back upon if the cache is over written. 

A program called GERoute has been created to automate the process of collecting Google Earth satellite imagery into the Google Earth cache.

From the same programmer is GE2KAP and now the latest version SAT2CHART, this program is used to create your own geo referenced satellite imagery (.KAP and .Mbtiles files/charts) for use in the chart repository of OpenCPN.  These files can be stored, backed up and shared with other cruisers. A better option than saving to cache.   

OpenCPN is a concise and robust open source chart plotting software. OpenCPN plugins are available to display the vessel in real time on both the electronic chart and Google Earth satellite imagery without the need for additional GPS connections to the computer. The display of Google Earth satellite imagery with the plugin can be from cache or live through an internet connection. Using this option you will not need to install GpsGate as the vessel position is displayed on the Google Earth satellite images using the single GPS connection used to position the vessel in OpenCPN. 

During passage planning another reason to scan over the charts is to get an idea of what’s out there. Once you have an idea of the path, zoom in the electronic chart for maximum detail and follow your route. It’s amazing the number of times we have heard of people hitting a reef/submerged object, all because they were not using a low enough zoom level and missed seeing the object they collided with.

Last but not least, sometimes you will not get a good satellite image to use. Look through the Historical Imagery to check all the previous images. Select different image providers. We have seen the sun reflection on the water masks detail, the same can be said about clouds covering the area. Most providers mix and match sections of the photos looking for a clear image and sometimes it just doesn’t happen. Luckily this doesn’t happen often but be aware of the problem, and search areas close by. 

Additional resources

Some cruisers write blogs and upload cruising information to websites. We spend time going through these resources before cruising off. But you need to look at the recent blogs, please keep in mind things change, sometimes overnight, as an example, an earth quake can change the sea floor in a flash. As I mentioned earlier, if you find the anchorages given in a blog don’t live up to the description then it might be time to disregard information from the source. Last but not least some cruising guides (even expensive ones) do get it wrong, be careful and do your homework.  

We have had to spend a lot of time working through others information to find out what was/is factual. It is like a lot of information these days, the data is not recorded correctly, speculation or opinion rather than fact is recorded. 


OpenCPN chart plotter https://opencpn.org/

OpenPlotter package of software to be run on a Raspberry Pi or unix Computer http://sailoog.com/openplotter or new site https://openmarine.net/
Google Earth OpenCPN plugin https://opencpn.org/OpenCPN/plugins/googleearth.htm
GpsGate             http://www.tiki-navigator.com/English/Franson_GpsGate.htm
GERoute  SAT2CHART and SASplanet http://www.gdayii.ca/Downloads.php
WXTIDE32 http://wxtide32.com/

Sources of shared Google Earth KAP files, Routes and Tracks: 

Also available Terry's Topics - OpenCPN Anchorage Waypoints and Satellite Charts (svsoggypaws.com) link to Terry’s vast collection of information is placed on Soggy Paws web site. Terry's Topics - OpenCPN Anchorage Waypoints and Satellite Charts (svsoggypaws.com) Terry also has a wealth of info to download, including help for setting up OpenCPN for those new to the program. 

Drawbacks-of-Using-Satellite-Imagery a description of some problems we found while getting and using satellite imagery 

Google Earth:

Do not install the latest version.  Google has removed the API that the OpenCPN plugin and GE2KAP, SAT2CHART and GERoute depends on. This bundle Google Earth Pro_7.3.1.45 works available for download from google. Oh, and once installed don’t hit the update key when the program opens the first and subsequent times. Then if you run chrome browser it will want to update google earth, I disable this function. How too can be found on line. 

And the best bit is the software listed above is free, however if you make good use of any that are not a commercial venture please donate to keep the wheels turning. 




Tuesday, 3 January 2023

One man’s datum is another man’s ship wreck

 Dramatic perhaps but the truth is if you are unfamiliar with or don’t have an understanding of chart datum the outcome could be an unhappy one. 

Looks like the chart datum was wrong for plotting satellite positions on.

While not a paper style chart this satellite photo chart is referenced to WGS 84 datum, the paper style chart can be seen poking out from under the satellite photo chart at the top..  


When cruising in new areas we have been given coordinates for anchorages and or hazards and when we arrive the reported depth of the anchorage is way out or the bottom is a rock or coral reef,  or the coordinates actually put us out on the point not in the bay. Yes there can be a multitude of reasons for the discrepancy however we did wonder if the positions were taken from charts produced with different datum. After several times trying to find a safe place to anchor in the dark with these coordinates from various sources, including guide books. We now always take time and plot the coordinates on google earth to check the waypoint is actually close to somewhere that looks usable. As a side note we have found its too late to do the check once you arrive due to lack of phone/internet coverage in some areas. 


I have used this screen shot to display the anchorage waypoints (referenced to WGS 84) displayed on a chart that is not referenced to WGS 84

We met up with a cruiser who had passed us a couple of anchorages that were nothing like he reported position depth and bottom. He was shocked to hear we had problems with the anchorages. We were now anchored about 40 metres apart and exchanged coordinates of our positions in the bay now. The expected out-come should have been thirty or forty metres apart as we were anchored behind one another, but the reality was that it was a substantial miss tie. So began the search for the discrepancy and as it turned out he didn't have a chartplotter and was using older paper charts and had his GPS receiver on the same datum as his charts. When he read off positions to pass on to others they should not have been plotted on a chartplotter or newer charts. He forgot to pass along the info that he was using an older datum not WGS84. We even know of others that use paper charts with a datum of unknown origin and use an external GPS to guess-ti-mate where they are on the chart. 

Look at the same anchorage waypoints on a satellite photo chart referenced to WGS 84, now there are some with no protection and are very exposed and one is high and dry.

Chart Datum

Datum; confusing it can be, and the source of the confusion starts with the type of datum. A datum is defined as any numerical or geometrical quantity or set of such quantities which serves as a reference point for other measurements. 

In cartography and marine navigation charts two types of datum must be considered: a horizontal datum and a vertical datum. The horizontal datum forms the basis for computations of horizontal position, in simple terms “where your at on the chart” lat and long. The vertical datum provides the reference for measuring heights and depths.  Again simply put, a standard base measurement so we know how deep the water is at high tide or how much clearance there will be going under that bridge. 

Horizontal Datum

Geodetic Datum is used in geodesy, navigation, surveying, cartography and satellite navigation systems to translate positions indicated on charts (paper or digital) to their real position on Earth.

Positioning systems, I will narrow that down to satellite positioning system datum (geodetic datum) and the chart on which that position is being displayed, need to match. If they don’t match, a hazard that you believe has been given sufficient clearance could well be about to take a chunk out of your keel. Similarly, the harbour entrance you believe you are approaching in a thick fog may actually be the break water wall not where you really want your vessel to be pointed.  

Knowing and understanding about the geodetic datum your GPS is using to calculate positions and the geodetic datum your chart has been modelled on can be the difference between a happy day out or one that may just end in tears. 

The latitude and longitude of places on a chart whether electronic or paper, depend on what mathematical model is used to represent the Earth. The challenge is that the Earth is an ellipsoidal, 3-dimensional surface, while the chart or map is a flat, 2-dimensional surface. 

A three dimensional surface, I always remember when I was in school the teacher would hold up the globe and pronounce to the class with the utmost authority the world was a perfectly round sphere just like a ball. 

Exaggerated shape perhaps, however not a perfectly round smooth ball. I hope the drawing gives an idea how the real shape of the earth comes about. 

Well our old teacher may have been partly correct, it may be like a ball but not the perfectly round sphere she was trying to make us believe it was. The real earth shape as it turns out it is more like a soccer ball that the big kids had been kicking around the school yard every recess time since forever. Yep flat spots, bulges and its starting to get flat spots on the top and bottom so it’s now more elliptical.     

All charts, whether paper or electronic, are represented as a mathematical model of the Earth. However, and as we know the shape of the Earth is not a perfect round and smooth sphere, so a mathematical model optimised for one country or continent may not suit another. For example the geodetic datum used for mapping the south pacific or Australia will certainly be different to the model used when mapping the Himalayas with all those hills and mountains. 

While the heights above the WGS 84 Ellipsoid are exaggerated I hope to just give an idea of how the datum may look in the real world.

Different mathematical model shapes are/were therefore used for mapping different areas of the earth. Within this variation, geodetic datum used for mapping individual countries usually will evolve over time due to new techniques and equipment. There will be differences between old and new charts if a new geodetic datum has been used during the production of the chart. Beware of charts produced with different datum’s in areas where they overlap. You will not be able to transfer a position to the next chart unless the position is converted to match the new chart datum. 

Once satellite positioning systems evolved a geodetic datum was needed to encompass the whole world, not just small sections. The model had to make the satellite received positions be within a few metres on the real world soccer ball.

The latest geodetic datum WGS84, is a mathematical model of the Earth intended as a compromise that idealistically represents the world for hands-on satellite navigation purposes. Yes there were earlier versions, WGS 66 WGS 72 and now WGS 84. You should find all of the latest commercial marine electronic charts are produced to use WGS 84. Like any chart whether paper or electronic they are not always totally accurate in every location.  Even with electronic charts you are still required to do  secondary checks to confirm your position on the chart, not many people do but its a worthwhile exercise. Especially when moving into a new area.   

In red the smooth calculated Ellipsoid that is used to smooth out the earths real shape. 

In Australia all ENC (Electronic Navigation Charts) and paper nautical charts published by the AHS (Australian Hydrographic Service) are compiled on WGS84 (World Geodetic Spheroid 1984) in accordance with international specifications. www.hydro.gov.au

Fairly standard Australian chart text box stating what Datum the chart maker has used.

However, not all other nation’s paper charts have been modernised to this international standard. Unfortunately, some of the older local datum (of various vintages) may have carried over from the original paper charts then into the apparently modern electronic ones when they were digitised. The differences can occasionally be as much as several hundred metres. If in doubt, always check your position by range and bearings to charted features. 

While its listed satellite positions cannot be plotted on this chart, we felt reference for chart Datum was ambiguous, it mentions surveys, but there is no mention of the Datum used in the surveys.   The Position warning here in the text box stating the Karang's (Bahasa for Reefs) being reported out of place turned up on a commercial electronic chart in the positions listed and didn't have a warning attached in the chart layers to explain the possible mis placed reefs.  

The electronic chart with the out of place reefs as noted in the paper chart text box. No such warnings listed on the electronic chart and these are plotted in the same position as the paper chart that cannot be referenced to WGS 84. So I would have a guess and say the electronic chart info was taken directly from the old paper chart that had no detail of datum listed. 

Your satellite positioning system should be set to give positions referenced to WGS84 when using any official electronic or paper nautical chart that have the Satellite Derived Positions reference box stating that WGS84 positions can be plotted directly on this chart.   WGS84 is typically the default datum used in most satellite positioning receivers. However in Australia if you are using older charts and the geodetic datum of the charts is AGD66 then you can select this geodetic datum in your GPS receiver and plot positions on the chart. However you need to confirm your GPS receiver is really changing the geodetic datum correctly. Tie up at a known point on the chart and or do several range and bearing sights (with RADAR works) to known chart objects. Keep in mind older charts can contain charted features that may no longer exist or have been rebuilt in another location.  

Satellite receiver’s datum settings

CHECK YOUR SATELLITE RECEIVER GEODETIC DATUM SETTINGS CAREFULLY – as I have written earlier all latitudes and longitudes which you use for navigation must relate to the same datum. It is worthwhile to check your GPS receiver before the start of a passage or a day out. Make sure the selected geodetic datum match the charts you’re using, as I said previously the manufactures of ENC’s use WGS84 as a standard, and paper charts are as marked.  If your using a tablet or smart phone for navigation, there is no way I know of to check the datum used, WGS84 should be the default if there isn't others to select from.  

Example settings screen showing that WGS 84 has been selected as Map Datum, not all receivers have this feature of additional datum to select. 

While this may sound crazy I’ve had a GPS receiver that had a fault and in several instances did change the geodetic datum all on its own somewhere during a passage.  I sent the receiver back to the manufactures a couple of times. Then after the fourth of fifth time rather than risk having a faulty receiver I put it in the bin.  At the time I was lucky to be operating in an area with a lot of beacons.  With a change of datum I found the beacons were a lot closer or further away than I would expect to find them and the first time it took me a while to work out why all the beacons were now in the middle of the channel. It’s a good thing I wasn’t trying to pass through an unmarked murky reef area.  

Importantly if your vessel has been tied up for a couple of weeks, has suffered a power failure or has undergone the installation of new equipment. You will certainly need to check over the settings on your chartplotter/GPS receiver. While it doesn’t happen all the time, simply installing new equipment can change the setting of other connected equipment, especially in this day and age of smart systems designed to be helpful. 

I have noticed one thing a lot of people get confused with, is the measurement on the GPS receiver display of elevation. You might notice the boat GPS receiver elevation display is -10 meters at the dock, at “sea level”.  The -10 meters is a perfectly accurate ellipsoidal height and as you know the dock isn’t 10 meters under water (or you would have bigger issues than interpreting an elevation measurement). So, although your GPS receiver’s ellipsoidal reading is accurate, it doesn’t seem to make sense unless you understand what it is.  The reason for the measurement is that the real earth surface is not a perfect smooth ellipsoid and as mentioned earlier, it does have a lot of flat spots. It also has mountains, craters, and other features above or below that mathematically perfect smooth ellipsoidal that is the reference E.g. WGS84.  The measurement you are seeing is more than likely because the patch of ocean your boat is floating in is on one of those flat spots as mentioned earlier.  Keep in mind that this measurement is not used for tidal height even though it is a vertical measurement from the ellipsoid datum. 


Vertical Datum AKA Tidal Datum

Tidal Datum is the water level that depths displayed on a nautical chart are measured from. Chart tidal datum is a vertical datum and not easy to confuse with the horizontal datum for the chart e.g. WGS84.  A chart vertical datum is generally derived from some phase of the tide.  

The most common chart tidal datum is LAT (lowest astronomical tide). Lowest Astronomical Tide, LAT for short is defined as the lowest tide level which can be predicted to occur under average meteorological conditions and under any combination of astronomical conditions. Many national charting agencies, including the Australian Hydrographic Service, use LAT to define chart datum.

Information box on paper chart, Chart Datum for horizontal WGS 84 and vertical reference LAT are defined. 

Chart information box, the satellite position WGS datum for applying corrections is not completely defined, its a real possibility of it being WGS 72. The good thing is the chart datum is listed as AGD 66.  The Datum for tide depths are referenced to Indian spring low water. Cross referencing to the newer format of LAT may not be straight forward.  
 
 Keep in mind this datum is continually changing as more precise methods of measurement are used, and the amount of data is analysed. 

One advantage of using LAT for chart datum is that all predicted tidal heights must then be positive (or zero) avoiding possible ambiguity and the need to explicitly state sign. Calculation of the LAT only allows for gravitational effects so in practice lower tides may occur due to other factors (e.g. meteorological effects such as high pressure systems). Charts show sounding in several ways, numbers denote individual soundings. These are supplemented by depth contours, lines connecting points of equal depth. These lines are used to present a picture of the bottom.


A tidal prediction harmonic, as can be seen here the lowest tide of the day is still a positive number above tide datum.  A numeric tide table in the top right corner make it easier to get the times correct. 

Charts and tables

Charted depths and drying heights on nautical charts are given relative to chart datum. Some height values on charts, such as vertical clearances under bridges or overhead wires, may be referenced to a different vertical datum, such as mean high water springs or highest astronomical tide (HAT) (for "HAT" see tidal range).

Most charts define the reference of the height of the vertical clearances under bridges or overhead wires in the info box list . Its good to see the clearance listed on the bridge as well. 

Tide tables give the height of the tide above a chart datum making it feasible to calculate the depth of water at a given point and at a given time by adding the charted depth to the height of the tide. One may calculate whether an area that dries is under water by subtracting the drying height from the [given] height calculated from the tide table.

Tide table example

Copy of Ashmore Reef, Australia
Units are meters

Tuesday 2023-01-03   
Sunrise  7:58 AM EAST, Sunset  7:45 PM EAST
Moonset  4:41 AM EAST, Moonrise  4:45 PM EAST
   Low Tide:   4:19 AM EAST   1.2
  High Tide:  10:24 AM EAST   2.4
   Low Tide:   3:43 PM EAST   1.6
  High Tide:  10:16 PM EAST   3.2

Wednesday 2023-01-04   
Sunrise  7:59 AM EAST, Sunset  7:45 PM EAST
Moonset  5:31 AM EAST, Moonrise  5:33 PM EAST
   Low Tide:   5:18 AM EAST   1.0
  High Tide:  11:30 AM EAST   2.5
   Low Tide:   4:47 PM EAST   1.6
  High Tide:  11:09 PM EAST   3.4

What has been known to happen when you get it wrong.  


A simple diagram showing tidal datum (black line) measurements of tide are referenced from the Datum.


Other defining terms.

Mean Sea Level (MSL) Long term average of the level of the sea, this is continually changing or evolving as more data is collected.

Mean Low Water Springs (MLWS) Long term average of the heights of low water at full and new moon.

Mean Low Water Neaps (MLWN) Long term average of the heights of low water at the first and third quarters of the moon. 

Mean High Water Springs (MHWS) Long term average of the heights of high water at full and new moon.

Mean Low Water Springs (MHWN) Long term average of the heights of low water at the first and third quarters of the moon.

Highest Astronomical Tide, HAT, Calculation of the HAT only allows for gravitational effects so higher or lower tides may occur due to other factors e.g. meteorological effects such as high or low pressure systems or storm cells. It is used, among other things as a datum from which to measure navigational clearance, or air draft, under bridges, power lines. 


Using charts and tables not based on the same geodetic datum can result in incorrect calculation of water depths.

So there can be errors creeping into chart vertical datum, if the conversion from one datum to another is not carefully controlled, the soundings can be changed. The same can be said for changes from metric to imperial or vice versa. 

 

Tuesday, 27 December 2022

Rough Guide to Monsoon Seasons, AU Top End & SE Asia

Weather, Almost everyone we talked to when we went into SE-Asia were a little confused when trying to work out the reasons for the two differing wind directions for the one monsoon season. The Intertropical Convergence Zone, or ITCZ, is the region that circles the Earth, near the equator, where the trade winds of the Northern and Southern Hemispheres come together. Sailing up in this area can be difficult at times, however if you can get a handle on the basics it really helps especially as some voyages will start in one hemisphere and end in another. 

Indonesia spans across the equator and you need to take this into account when you are reading about which weather patterns fall in which month. We didn't one time and as it turns out were not pleasantly surprised. Indonesia doesn't get a summer or winter its either the wet season or dry season the notation on the list below is more to denote the hemisphere season. Also of note is the dry/wet is not the whole of Indonesia in the same season.


Southern Hemisphere Indonesia                              Northern Hemisphere Indonesia
N-West monsoon Dec-Jan-Feb   (S Summer)          N-East monsoon Dec-Jan-Feb     (N Winter)
First transition Mar-Apr-May                                  First transition Mar-Apr-May
S-East monsoon Jun-Jul-Aug     (S Winter)             S-West monsoon Jun-Jul-Aug     (N Summer)
Second transition Sep-Oct-Nov                                 Second transition Sep-Oct-Nov


Bruce's rough guide to the monsoon seasons on both side of the equator. 

Winds change through the year.

During December and January, the Southern Hemisphere is heated more strongly by the Sun than the Northern Hemisphere, so the hottest air — the air that rises in the ITCZ — is found south of the equator. Winds from the Northern Hemisphere blow across the equator toward the ITCZ.

During June and July, the Northern Hemisphere is heated more strongly by the Sun, so the ITCZ and its rising hot air lie north of the equator and winds blow from the Southern Hemisphere across the equator to reach the ITCZ in the Northern Hemisphere.

As the ITCZ changes location through the year, the winds and rains and the location of monsoon wet weather changes, too.

-----

Remember that the Coriolis force changes direction on the equator: It turns winds toward the right in the Northern Hemisphere (so a SE in the Southern Hemisphere turn SW in the northern Hemisphere) Wind turns toward the left in the Southern Hemisphere (so a NE in the Northern Hemisphere becomes North West in the Southern Hemisphere).

So when air crosses the equator as it flows from the cold winter hemisphere toward the ITCZ in the summer hemisphere, it experiences a change in the Coriolis force. This causes the trade winds to reverse direction and blow toward the west in the winter hemisphere and to the east in the summer hemisphere.

This seasonal reversal of the winds was historically very important for trade between Africa and Asia. Ships would sail from Asia to Africa in winter and then undertake their return voyage when the summer monsoon changed the wind from westward to eastward.

Winds within a couple of degrees of the equator are generally “light and variable” all the time. Weather forecasts are rarely accurate in these areas. Make sure you have a cruising spinnaker and as a back up, an engine. Winds are spasmodic and currents are/can be quite strong depending where you are.

------------------------

SE / SW Monsoon Season

While the drawing I have done is a little rough I hope the fundamental idea makes sense. 

During the months of June-September dry season trade winds blow consistently from the SE and ESE throughout the Southern Islands of Indonesia. Trade winds are stronger in Eastern Indonesia and areas around Timor and the Arafura Sea than they are further to the West near Lombok, Bali, Java and Sumatra.

Further North as SE trade winds approach the equator they lose considerable strength and veer from SE to a very light S. Then, once across the equator and into the northern hemisphere, due to the Coriolis effect, these light S winds again veer from S to SW and slightly increase in strength. It is for this reason that we sometimes refer to this season as the SE/SW monsoon season.

Precipitation on both sides of the equator is at odds. While Bali and Java experience dry season trade winds out of the SE, the areas of northern Sumatra, Kalimantan, Sulawesi, Morotai and Thailand will be in their SW monsoon wet season.

NE / NW Monsoon Season



During the months of December-February NE winds blow in the northern hemisphere and across the top of Indonesia. As these NE winds approach the equator they lose strength and back to the N. Once across the equator, because of the Coriolis effect, winds back further and increase in strength to become the NW monsoon wet-season for much of Southern Indonesia. Southern Sumatra, Southern Sulawesi, Java, Bali, Flores, Timor, and Rote will all experience strong westerly winds and rainy conditions for much of this period with the height of the wet season falling in February.

Clear sky's and calms are often experienced in between passing storm systems.

Cyclones can develop in the Timor, Coral and Arafura Seas and this area should be monitored if passing near Timor and Rote Islands during the NE/NW monsoon season.

Transitional Seasons

Some nice cruising can be had during the changing of the seasons. Winds are often light to non-existent with only short duration squalls passing through. Some of the more exposed and windy areas of Indonesia are often calm and pleasant and open to exploration at this time. With the sun directly over the equator and calms likely, conditions can be very hot. The ITCZ can move by as much as a thousand miles overnight or not move at all and sometimes will appear in two places at once. With such changing conditions occasional late or early season weather does develop.

--------------------------------------------

We have found that neither the GFS nor the ECMWF do a good job of forecasting winds in Indonesia. Generally they get the direction right, but wind strength is hit and miss. Weather forecasts (GRIB files) in the Malacca Strait never seem to be right either, perhaps this is just our observation because, we possibly never got far enough off shore to get away from its effects.

Here is a reasonable explanation of the monsoon seasons:

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-01-18/monsoon-explaining-the-complex-weather-phenomenon/10722716

Malacca Strait

The weather description below is for the Malacca Strait (Selat Melaka), being a passage between Peninsular Malaysia and Indonesian Sumatra there are a couple of anomalies. When using any of the Island anchorages, be prepared to get underway at a moments notice. After being caught, we would work out an action plan to get to the other side quickly. If we were lucky, once the front passed there would be a calm for a couple of hours after the storm, before the wind returns to its original direction.

Northern Hemisphere Melaka Strait

Northeast Monsoon - November to March

This is the dry season. The winds are predominantly from the NE from 10 to 20 knots, with occasional winds up to 30 knots. There are frequent calms lasting from a few hours (often in the evenings and early morning) to whole days or a few days duration. Rain is very rare and the days are fine and relatively cool as the sun is at its furthest south at this time (in December the sun is only 60 degrees above the horizon at midday) - Very pleasant cruising weather and because the wind is coming straight off the Malaysian peninsular there is no swell and any seas that do come up during local strong winds drop quickly when the wind drops.

Transition period - April and May

This is the height of the transition period between the NE and SW monsoons and is marked by many calms, very light winds and flat seas. When there is wind it can come from any direction and vary in strength and direction, but is not common from the East through to South or from the North. There is the odd rain squall that can last from five minutes to an hour or two with winds sometimes up to 25 knots under them.

Very little chance of a "Sumatra" (see SW Monsoon). Hot, sultry weather.

Southwest monsoon - June to September (Some years into late October)

This is the wet season. Hot, sultry weather as the sun is in the North and the humidity is high. The winds are predominantly from the SW from.10 to 25 knots, with frequent calms and frequent rain squalls. The rain squalls last from a few minutes to a few hours but typically last for about 15 minutes with very heavy rain and either no wind or, more frequently, winds up to 25 knots. These winds change strength and direction depending on your position relative to the centre of the squall.

Once they have passed over, the skies clear and the wind returns to its condition before the squall arrived. A squall can usually be seen well before it arrives as an isolated large, dark, towering cloud and, should you be close to land or rocks, gives you plenty of time to either anchor or head for an open area before the heavy rain causes a complete whiteout.

This is the season for "Sumatra" winds.

"SUMATRA" winds are a different matter altogether. In the day they can easily be identified as a long rolling bank of very dark cloud extending roughly North and South from horizon to horizon and coming from the West from Sumatra, thus their name. At night, when they are most common, the first warning is when they hit. They are most common in the South Malacca Straits, but do occur occasionally around Penang ,and Langkawi, though they are rarer around Phuket. Typically there will be two to four during this season in Penang and one or Penang and one or two in Phuket. There is no avoiding the very strong (up to 60 knot)\ Westerly quarter wind that just precedes the cloud bank and very heavy rain. They can last for five or more hours, though more commonly last for from about 20 minutes to one hour and then end as quickly as they began.

Transition period - October

Same as the Transition period from April to May.

This is the height of the transition period between the SW and NE monsoons and is marked by many calms, very light winds and flat seas. When there is wind it can come from any direction and vary in strength and direction, but is not common from the East through to South or from the North. There is the odd rain squall that can last from five minutes to an hour or two with winds sometimes up to 25 knots under them.

Very little chance of a "Sumatra" (see SW Monsoon). Hot, sultry weather.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Red sky at night sailors delight; red sky in the morning sailors take warning.”

There is a simple explanation for this. When the sun is on the horizon, its light, shining at an angle, must pass through more atmosphere.

Red is the colour of the spectrum with the longest wavelengths and can therefore reach all the way through to where water vapour and dust is denser. Here it reflects off the vapour and dust projecting a red light to our eye. In mid latitudes storms predominantly move from west to east.

Red sky at night sailors delight" So when the sunset in the west reflects off particles of a low pressure in the east, creating the red lit sky, the weather has past making way for improved (delightful) conditions.

"Red sky in the morning sailors take warning" So then if the sunrise in the east reflects off particles of a low pressure in the west, making the red lit sky, we can assume that storms are approaching, sailors take warning the weather should worsen.